WEST LIBERTY, W.Va. — For Andrew "Andy" Schumacher, his time at West Liberty University was about more than football. It was about the coaches who believed in him, the teammates who became lifelong friends and the experiences that helped shape his life long after his playing days ended.
A native of Woodsfield, Ohio, Schumacher played defensive line for the Hilltoppers from 1988-91, establishing himself as one of the top defensive players in the program's history. A member of West Liberty's Class of 1992, he earned three All-West Virginia Intercollegiate Athletic Conference selections and back-to-back NAIA All-America honorable mention honors.
Schumacher made an immediate impact, earning West Liberty's Defensive Freshman of the Year recognition. He went on to collect multiple WVIAC Defensive Player of the Week honors and finished his career among the most accomplished defensive linemen to wear the Black and Gold.
His senior season in 1991 was especially memorable. Schumacher broke West Liberty's single-game and single-season quarterback sack records, and he still ranks fourth on the program's all-time sack list. His single-game record of eight tackles for loss has stood for more than three decades.
Schumacher's path to West Liberty began with a visit that he never forgot. During the summer of 1988, defensive coordinator Bob Eaton drove to a hayfield in Monroe County, Ohio, to recruit him. Unsure whether he belonged at the college level,
Schumacher was encouraged by Eaton's confidence, energy and passion for the game.
Eaton ultimately convinced him to give college football a try, and Schumacher credits the coach as the reason he chose West Liberty.
His four years with the Hilltoppers also included a long list of influential coaches and teammates. Schumacher remembers the defensive staff, including Eaton, Reggie, Vaquez, Dugas, T.C. and others, for developing a close-knit unit that took tremendous pride in its pursuit and defensive effort.
Among his teammates, captain Dirk Winkler stood out as a role model. Schumacher admired Winkler's professionalism, work ethic and commitment to lifting weights and studying film. He also fondly remembers teammates Mike "Ox" McCafferty, Emilio Traversa, Shawn Schwertfeger, Greg Moray, Mark Richards, Mark Doyle and many others who made lasting impressions during his time on campus.
Some of Schumacher's favorite memories, however, had little to do with statistics or game results. He recalls the camaraderie in the football locker room, the old jukebox, spending time on the steps of Beta Hall and competing in intramural sports. The football players even captured an intramural basketball championship.
One of his favorite stories came from the practice field, where a local fan would occasionally stop by after practice and ask to carry Schumacher's helmet back to the fieldhouse. The gesture made him feel like he was playing for the Green Bay Packers.
More than 30 years later, those memories remain an important part of what West Liberty means to him. Schumacher takes pride in being part of the university's close-knit Black and Gold family, remembering the professors, friendships and welcoming atmosphere that made his experience special. He also recalls former President Dr. Clyde Campbell for making everyone feel welcome.
Following his graduation, Schumacher pursued a career in education, finding a way to combine his interests in hands-on work and helping others. Today, he teaches construction trades to sophomores, juniors and seniors at Swiss Hills Career Center in the Switzerland of Ohio School District. His classes cover carpentry, masonry, residential electricity, plumbing, drywall and general labor.
Outside the classroom, Schumacher operates a small carpentry business and maintains a working farm with cattle. He also enjoys one of his most important roles — being a grandfather to his grandsons, Otto and Isaac, who know him affectionately as "Pa."
When asked what advice he would offer today's student-athletes, Schumacher keeps it simple: work hard, enjoy the journey and compete with an old-school toughness.
He encourages Hilltoppers to play with passion, focus and intensity from whistle to whistle, adding that there will be time to rest later.
It is advice shaped by a career built on effort, pursuit and commitment — the same qualities that made Schumacher a standout defensive lineman and helped him earn a place among West Liberty's all-time greats.
Inducted into the West Liberty Athletics Hall of Fame in 2024, Schumacher remains proud of his connection to the university and the people who made his experience unforgettable. For him, being a Hilltopper is about more than the accomplishments on the field. It is about the friendships, the memories and the family atmosphere that continue long after the final whistle.
Q&A With Andy Schumacher
What sport did you play or coach at West Liberty, and when?
Football, 1988-1992.
What was your major?
Business Administration.
What are you doing now?
I teach sophomores, juniors and seniors carpentry, masonry, residential electricity, plumbing, drywall and labor in the Construction Trades program at Swiss Hills Career Center. I also do a little carpentry business work on the side and operate a small working farm with cattle.
What is your favorite memory of West Liberty?
Thinking back, some of my favorite memories have to be the locker room camaraderie of the football team and that old jukebox. The defensive unit over the years, coached by Coach Eaton, Coach Reggie, Coach Vaquez, Coach Dugas, T.C. and others, was a tight-knit group that took pride in being among the top pursuing defenses in the conference. The pursuit drill was something special!
I also loved hanging out on the steps of Beta Hall. Intramural softball and the football guys winning an intramural basketball championship were favorite memories. Another funny memory was when one of the locals would come down to the practice field and, after practice, ask to carry my helmet back to the fieldhouse. He made me feel like I played for the Green Bay Packers!
What advice would you give to current student-athletes?
Work hard and feel good together. Play with that old-school tough mentality, whistle to whistle. Play with passion, focus and intensity. Rest later!
What does being a West Liberty alumnus mean to you?
I am very proud to be part of the Black and Gold, close-knit family-type culture at West Liberty. There were great professors, and I made long-lasting friendships. President Dr. Clyde Campbell made everyone feel so welcome.
Who were the most influential coaches or teammates during your time at West Liberty?
Back in the summer of 1988, Coach Bob Eaton had just been hired as the defensive coordinator at West Liberty and literally drove out into a hayfield in Monroe County and asked me to come play for him. At the time, I didn't know if I belonged at the college level. He showed confidence in me and impressed me so much with his energy and passion for the sport that he convinced me to give it a try.
Coach, you're "My Man!" Coach Bob Eaton is the sole reason I attended West Liberty and played football. I truly had a spectacular four years around Coach Eaton and coaches Reggie, T.C., Dugas, Shank, Vaquez, Cookie, Crookie, all the coaches and all the guys and staff.
Teammate and captain Dirk Winkler was a role model — a middle linebacker with a professional attitude who set the tone through working out and watching film. Along with Mike "Ox" McCafferty, Spikey, T-Bone, Grudgy, Lance, Smoothie, Emilio Traversa, Burger Brown, Mark Doyle, Chief Shawn Schwertfeger, Greg Moray, Mark Richards, Jimmy E. and Neffy, there were so many studs, buddies and influential people during my time at West Liberty.
There are too many friends to name and teammates who made lasting impressions in my life.